The Miami Dolphins are at a crucial juncture with Tua Tagovailoa’s future as their starting quarterback. The recent addition of Zach Wilson, signed on the first day of NFL Free Agency, has introduced a level of competition that can’t be overlooked. It raises the stakes for Tagovailoa, who now finds himself in a more precarious position than ever.
As the team prepares for the 2025 season, Wilson’s signing is not just about adding depth; it signals a shift in the team’s strategy moving forward. With a contract worth $6 million, potentially rising to $10 million, the Dolphins are clearly invested in Wilson’s development and readiness to lead.
Tua’s track record has been troubling in terms of consistency and health. Last season, his absence due to concussions forced the Dolphins to alternate between Skylar Thompson and Tyler Huntley—neither of whom instilled the kind of confidence a contending team needs. Over his career, Tagovailoa has missed ten games, and during those contests, Miami’s record stands at a disappointing 3-7. While he’s shown flashes of talent, the reality is that his inability to stay on the field is a significant concern for a franchise looking to make a serious push this season.
Enter Zach Wilson, who, despite a rocky start with the Jets—throwing for 6,293 yards along with 23 touchdowns and 25 interceptions—brings a different dynamic to the Dolphins’ lineup. His previous struggles can partially be attributed to a challenging situation in New York, where the offensive system never fully catered to his strengths and where he faced inconsistent support from his receiving corps. Interestingly, Wilson spent the entire 2024 season learning behind Bo Nix with the Denver Broncos, which allowed him to absorb new concepts and refine his game under Sean Payton—a valuable experience that could pay dividends in Miami.
Wilson has the arm strength and mobility that can thrive in Mike McDaniel’s offensive scheme, which emphasizes versatility and quick decision-making. The potential is there for Wilson to elevate the Dolphins’ offense and potentially claim the title of franchise quarterback if he harnesses his skills effectively.
For Tua, the pressure is mounting. Should he falter, it won’t be long before Wilson seizes the opportunity to take the reins. The Dolphins’ hopes for a competitive season hinge on how well Tagovailoa can navigate his health issues and regain his starting role’s stability. Meanwhile, Wilson is poised to make the most of any chances that come his way, eyeing an opportunity for redemption in Miami. The coming months will undoubtedly shape the trajectory of both quarterbacks and the franchise as a whole.