As the Miami Dolphins weigh the decision on whether to offer quarterback Tua Tagovailoa a substantial contract extension, concerns about the prudence of such a financial commitment are mounting. With the presence of dynamic talents like Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle, and the support of renowned coach Mike McDaniel and a bolstered defense led by Vic Fangio and Jalen Ramsey, Tagovailoa has certainly had an advantageous setup. Yet, the looming question remains: Could another quarterback achieve similar, if not greater, success under the same conditions, and at a potentially lower cost?
Tagovailoa is due to play the 2024 season under his fifth-year option, with a guaranteed $23.2 million salary. With quarterback contracts escalating, as seen with Jared Goff’s $53 million annual deal featuring $170 million guaranteed, Tua’s agents are likely eyeing a similar figure. Considering the financial implications, it’s worth exploring whether such an investment in Tagovailoa would preclude the Dolphins from retaining or acquiring other key players.
Despite leading the NFL in passing yards, Tagovailoa’s durability raises significant concerns, with a history of injuries ranging from concussions to issues with his ankle and knee. Furthermore, his performance in critical high-stakes games and during the playoffs has yet to convincingly demonstrate that he can elevate the Dolphins to championship contention.
Looking ahead, Miami might consider alternative quarterback options poised to become available. Mac Jones and Jimmy Garoppolo, both set for free agency in 2025, have shown potential in systems that maximize their abilities as efficient game managers.
Jones, in particular, showcased his capabilities with the Patriots, suggesting he might thrive with Miami’s elite offensive tools. Meanwhile, Garoppolo’s familiarity with McDaniel’s strategies from their time in San Francisco could make him a seamless fit.
Other possible candidates include Sam Darnold, who will have an opportunity to prove himself with the Vikings, and either Geno Smith or Sam Howell, depending on who emerges as the starter for the Seahawks. As cost-effective alternatives or potential stopgaps, these options could offer financial flexibility while maintaining competitive performance.
Additionally, the Dolphins could explore the 2025 NFL Draft for emerging talents like Shadeur Sanders or Quinn Ewers, broadening their long-term strategic options.
Ultimately, while retaining Tagovailoa might ensure continuity and competitive performances, it could also bind the Dolphins financially, restricting their ability to enhance the team comprehensively and possibly hindering their Super Bowl aspirations. As such, Miami must carefully evaluate not only Tagovailoa’s direct impact and health prognosis but also the broader implications of a hefty contract on the team’s future success and flexibility.